{ "schemaVersion": 2, "checkedAt": "2026-11-02", "comparator": "Tarnished.dev public v1.17 UI, same effective inputs, two independent Chromium reads per accepted case", "meaning": "Finite evidence-based scope; not all-game or all-calculator parity.", "baseData": { "weaponWeight": { "total": 487, "siteVerified": 487, "unobservable": 0, "status": "CLOSED_VERIFIED" }, "weaponMinimumRequirement": { "total": 487, "siteVerified": 460, "unobservable": 27, "status": "CLOSED_UI_UNOBSERVABLE_REMAINDER" }, "legacyArmorWeightPoise": { "total": 568, "siteVerified": 549, "unobservable": 19, "status": "CLOSED_UI_UNOBSERVABLE_REMAINDER" }, "armorNeutralTwelveFields": { "siteVerified": 515, "legacyApproved": 514, "extraDlcApproved": 1, "fieldsPerItem": 12, "status": "CLOSED_FOR_VERIFIED_ITEMS_ONLY" }, "originalClasses": { "total": 10, "siteVerified": 10, "status": "CLOSED_VERIFIED" }, "nakedBaseVitals": { "referenceCases": 360, "status": "CLOSED_FOR_OBSERVED_INPUTS" }, "exactGlintstonePebbleStaffScenes": { "observed": 18, "independentCalculatedMatches": 18, "observedInt": [ 20, 25, 30, 35, 40, 45, 50, 55, 60, 65, 70, 75, 80, 85, 90, 95, 98, 99 ], "status": "CLOSED_FOR_IDENTICAL_INPUTS_ONLY" }, "isolatedTalismanScenes": { "items": 14, "status": "CLOSED_FOR_IDENTICAL_INPUTS_ONLY" }, "combinedTalismanScenes": { "profiles": 5, "status": "CLOSED_FOR_IDENTICAL_INPUTS_ONLY" }, "damageUchigatanaAr": { "profiles": 3, "status": "CLOSED_FOR_IDENTICAL_INPUTS_ONLY" }, "exactGreatGlintstoneShardScenes": { "observed": 3, "independentCalculatedMatches": 3, "independentBrowserPasses": 2, "spell": "Great Glintstone Shard", "staff": "Astrologer's Staff", "upgrade": 25, "intelligence": [ 40, 60, 80 ], "observedMagic": [ 437, 570, 646 ], "sourceRun": 41371710168, "status": "CLOSED_FOR_THREE_IDENTICAL_INPUTS_ONLY" }, "otherSorceryExactScenes": { "distinctSpellKinds": 4, "unchargedRows": 11, "chargedCometRows": 2, "allRows": 13, "independentChromiumPasses": 2, "realReferenceRuns": [ 41371710168, 41373017465, 41373171565 ], "scope": "Only named Wretch baseline other attributes 10 and Astrologer +25, no buffs and target 0/0" }, "crossCatalystSpellScenes": { "newScenarios": 17, "verifiedTotalScenarios": 62, "doublyReadSourceRun": 41376397795, "sourcePasses": 2, "allIndependentNumericalMatches": true, "scope": "Four existing spell kinds with Academy Glintstone Staff at +20/+25; Comet charged primary projectile only" }, "twoNewSorceryScenes": { "newScenarios": 8, "distinctSpellNames": 2, "independentChromiumPasses": 2, "workflowRun": 41377415394, "exactMatch": true } }, "notComparableWithoutMoreImplementation": [ { "module": "Armor Optimizer", "status": "NOT_PARITY_CERTIFIED", "blocker": "Full DLC candidate pool and exact reference 13-metric score, constraints and top-five tie/rank algorithm not established" }, { "module": "Damage Calculator", "status": "NOT_PARITY_CERTIFIED", "blocker": "Reference weapon moveset frames/motion values, enemy defenses/negations, NG+ and PvP hit/DPS pipeline missing" }, { "module": "Spell Calculator", "status": "PARTIAL_ONLY", "blocker": "Five distinct single-projectile sorcery types now have 37 doubly observed zero-defense source-site exact-input goldens (including ordinary and charged Comet primary projectile), but all other spells/incantations, school buffs, hybrid catalysts, multi-target splash, real enemy defense and current game-client 1.17.3 remain unverified." }, { "module": "Build Planner", "status": "NOT_PARITY_CERTIFIED", "blocker": "Arbitrary talisman/armor/Physick/Great Rune/active-buff interactions and conditional downstream effects not independently modeled or reference-tested" } ], "stopRule": "Do not rerun completed 487/487 weights, 460/487 visible requirements, 549/568 legacy armor or 18 spell scenarios merely to raise counts. No numerical goldens for site-unobservable items. Remaining work is actual feature implementation and same-input acceptance, not rechecking baseline tables.", "sources": [ "docs/TARNISHED_V117_FINAL_487_WEIGHT_EVIDENCE_20261101.md", "docs/TARNISHED_V117_FINAL_487_REQUIREMENTS_EVIDENCE_20261101.md", "docs/TARNISHED_V117_REMAINING_ONLY_FINAL_AUDIT_20261101.md", "docs/TARNISHED_V117_FINAL_SCOPE_ACCEPTANCE_20261101.md", "docs/TARNISHED_V117_SPELL_ONE_POINT_UNIFIED_ROUNDING_FIX_20261102.md", "docs/FOUR_ENGINE_REAL_SITE_ACCEPTANCE_20261102.md", "docs/V117_ACADEMY_STAFF_REAL_PARITY_20261102.md", "docs/V117_ACADEMY_PLUS20_SPELL_AND_NONZERO_TARGET_BOUNDARY_20261102.md", "docs/V117_RUNE_PHYSICK_SELECTED_COMBO_20261102.md", "docs/FOUR_ENGINE_ONE_SHOT_FINAL_DISPOSITION_20261102.md", "scripts/v117-great-shard-double-browser-evidence.json", "scripts/v117-three-other-sorceries-double-browser-evidence.json", "docs/FIVE_SORCERY_REAL_PARITY_AND_FOUR_ENGINE_PROGRESS_20261102.md" ], "finalFourEngineDecision": { "asOf": "2026-11-02", "baselineRef": "main@70b1ad9acaa9bcecbc4768d93343ca40310e1d2b", "referenceVersion": "Tarnished.dev public v1.17, not certified game client 1.17.3", "question": "Which calculator behavior is demonstrably accepted, and what is blocked without independent source evidence?", "decision": "CLOSE_REPEAT_AUDIT; APPROVE_FINITE_SCENES_ONLY; DO_NOT_MARK_FOUR_ENGINES_FULL_PARITY", "acceptedModules": 0, "limitedScopeModules": 4, "wholeGameParityCertified": false, "evidenceStandard": "Real same-effective-input two independent browser observations plus independently calculated results; mathematical unit tests without reference are LOCAL_ONLY", "modules": { "armor": { "overall": "LIMITED_LOCAL_FUNCTION_ACCEPTED__REFERENCE_TOP5_PARITY_NOT_CERTIFIED", "accepted": [ "Local exact four-slot top-5 optimizer for 13 selectable weighted metrics and declared constraints; independent brute-force test oracle", "One reference Poise-only Wretch medium-load maximum of 70 observed in a specific constrained scene", "549 source-identified original armor weight/Poise pairs and 515 accepted stat-neutral 12-field items retained without rerun", "Actual public v1.17 Poise-only Top10 rank table twice observed; source order explicitly retained, tie-breaking/candidate pool NOT independently reproduced (run 41376492510)" ], "notAccepted": [ "Tarnished.dev top-five exact order and tie-breaking", "Complete DLC candidate pool and effects", "Exact parity of all 13 reference weighting/limit semantics" ], "blockers": [ "Legal, versioned complete DLC armor candidate catalogue including contextual stat-changing effects", "An independent same-input 13-metric reference score/rank dataset with exact settings and tie cases" ], "evidence": [ "docs/ARMOR_EXACT_WEIGHTED_TOP5_20261102.md", "tests/armor-weighted-top-five.test.mjs" ], "release": "RESEARCH_NOINDEX_ONLY" }, "damage": { "overall": "LIMITED_MANUAL_SEQUENCE_ACCEPTED__REAL_DPS_PARITY_NOT_CERTIFIED", "accepted": [ "User-entered attack channels, per-hit motion values, target defense/negation and per-move timing; deterministic mathematical DPS from entered frames", "Three observed +25 Standard Uchigatana source AR values 376,388,392; these are AR, not real enemy damage", "Browser and unit tests cover per-hit values, frame validation and per-hit defense application", "Four real one-handed Uchigatana +25 named action source results: R1 1=294, R1 2=298, R2 1=389, Charged R2 1=526; independently recomputed from four separately sourced Katana motion values and fixed site default 100 defense in two independent Chromium sessions (run 41379244818)" ], "notAccepted": [ "Automated per-weapon animation and recovery frames", "Versioned enemy defense/negation, NG+ and PvP scaling", "Tarnished.dev moveset DPS numeric equivalence; real in-game damage", "Real reference Physical Defense field changed 100 to 150, but same four displayed hit values persisted; target sensitivity and display propagation are not certified" ], "blockers": [ "Verifiable versioned enemy per-type defense/negation, NG+ and PvP parameters", "Move-specific motion values, frame timings and real same-input damage/DPS goldens" ], "evidence": [ "docs/FOUR_ENGINE_REAL_SITE_ACCEPTANCE_20261102.md", "tests/damage-moveset-sequence.test.mjs", "tests/damage-per-hit-ui.test.mjs", "public/src/v117-four-uchi-real-moves.mjs", "tests/v117-four-uchi-real-moves.test.mjs", "docs/V117_FOUR_UCHI_REAL_ATTACKS_TWO_DEFENSES_20261102.md" ], "release": "MANUAL_MODEL_ONLY__NO_CLAIM_OF_GAME_PARITY" }, "spell": { "overall": "LIMITED_EXACT_REFERENCE_SCENES_ACCEPTED__GENERAL_SPELL_PARITY_NOT_CERTIFIED", "accepted": [ "18 separately observed Astrologer's Staff +25 Glintstone Pebble exact-input local matches", "4 separately observed Academy Glintstone Staff +25 Glintstone Pebble exact-input local matches", "2 separately observed Academy Glintstone Staff +20 Glintstone Pebble exact-input local matches", "3 newly independent double-browser Great Glintstone Shard +25 Astrologer's Staff scenes INT40/60/80 match separately sourced AtkParam 211 coefficient and pinned catalyst arithmetic exactly", "Seven named sorceries have 62 directly compared real v1.17 double-Chromium scenes: original 37, 17 cross-catalyst scenes, and 8 new Night Comet/Magic Glintblade normal/charged scenes at INT60/80; independently computed from source attack coefficients and correction graphs" ], "exactTotal": 62, "exactByStaffAndUpgrade": [ { "staff": "Astrologer's Staff", "level": 25, "scenes": 18 }, { "staff": "Academy Glintstone Staff", "level": 25, "scenes": 4 }, { "staff": "Academy Glintstone Staff", "level": 20, "scenes": 2 } ], "actualSpellKindsCovered": 7, "zeroDefenseComparatorOnly": true, "notAccepted": [ "Every other spell/incantation beyond seven named simple sorceries, including seals, status, school effects, multiple projectiles, splash, special attacks, mixed catalysts and all spell buffs", "Spell/equipment buffs, alternative catalyst correction modes", "Damage against nonzero enemy defense/negation: public v1.17 reference page has no such input controls" ], "blockers": [ "Versioned attack-parameter/spell coefficient and seal/catalyst tables plus independent exact-input numeric scenes for other spells", "Independent in-game damage observations for nonzero target-defense cases; reference UI alone cannot prove them" ], "evidence": [ "scripts/tarnished-v117-spell-18-consensus-goldens.json", "scripts/tarnished-v117-academy-staff-goldens.json", "scripts/v117-academy-plus20-double-browser-evidence.json", "docs/V117_ACADEMY_PLUS20_SPELL_AND_NONZERO_TARGET_BOUNDARY_20261102.md", "scripts/v117-great-shard-double-browser-evidence.json", "scripts/check-v117-great-shard-independent.mjs", "tests/v117-great-shard-real-parity.test.mjs", "scripts/v117-three-other-sorceries-double-browser-evidence.json", "scripts/check-v117-five-sorceries-independent.mjs", "tests/v117-five-sorceries-independent.test.mjs" ], "release": "SCOPED_EXACT_REFERENCE_ONLY__NONZERO_DEFENSE_ESTIMATE", "attributedSimpleUnchargedSourceSpellKinds": 5, "exactSecondSpell": { "name": "Great Glintstone Shard", "staff": "Astrologer's Staff", "upgrade": 25, "scenes": 3, "sourceRun": 41371710168 }, "exactAdditionalSpells": [ { "spell": "Swift Glintstone Shard", "ordinary": 3, "charged": 0, "sourceRun": 41373017465 }, { "spell": "Glintstone Arc", "ordinary": 3, "charged": 0, "sourceRun": 41373017465 }, { "spell": "Comet", "ordinary": 2, "charged": 2, "ordinarySourceRun": 41373017465, "chargedSourceRun": 41373171565 } ], "crossCatalystAdditional": { "scenes": 17, "browserRun": 41376397795, "independentBrowserPasses": 2, "contexts": [ "Academy Glintstone Staff +25 Great Glintstone Shard", "Academy Glintstone Staff +25 Swift Glintstone Shard", "Academy Glintstone Staff +20 Glintstone Arc", "Academy Glintstone Staff +20/+25 Comet (normal and charged primary projectile)" ] }, "additionalTwoSpells": { "names": [ "Magic Glintblade", "Night Comet" ], "scenes": 8, "independentBrowserPasses": 2, "workflowRun": 41377415394, "independentCoefficients": [ "https://eldenring.wiki.gg/wiki/Magic_Glintblade", "https://eldenring.wiki.gg/wiki/Night_Comet" ], "status": "8_OF_8_IDENTICAL_CONTEXT_CALCULATIONS_MATCH" } }, "build": { "overall": "LIMITED_EXACT_SELECTED_SCENES_ACCEPTED__ARBITRARY_STACKS_NOT_CERTIFIED", "accepted": [ "10 original starting classes / 360 naked-vitals baseline scenes", "14 isolated talisman scenes and five explicit combined talisman scenes", "Four independent live reference Rune/Physick switch-state scenarios (OFF/OFF; OFF/ON; ON/OFF; ON/ON), twice observed with eight attributes + HP/FP/Stamina/Equip Load/Physical Defense/Magic Defense, run 41376804251", "One NEW real v1.17 Wretch10 Starscourge Heirloom + Godrick Rune + INT-knot Tear three-category stacking case: all four real switch states, 32 independently recomputed final stats; reference-only HP/FP/stamina/defenses, run 41379657078" ], "referenceToggles": { "greatRune": "explicit ON/OFF four scenarios", "physick": "explicit ON/OFF four scenarios" }, "notAccepted": [ "Rune Arc lifetime/duration, other Runes and Tears, arbitrary buff/gear stacking; four reference-site selected activation combinations are now verified", "Arbitrary multi-item stacks including conditional armor, buffs and equipment interaction order", "General derived HP, FP, defenses, negation, weapon AR and damage for those arbitrary combinations" ], "blockers": [ "Versioned active-effect and stacking-order rules validated in real client or independently auditable same-input display", "Cross-category numerical benchmarks including untested activation contexts, equipment and dependent outputs, not merely selected-item eight-stat changes" ], "evidence": [ "docs/V117_RUNE_PHYSICK_SELECTED_COMBO_20261102.md", "tests/v117-rune-physick-selected-combo.test.mjs", "tests/v117-independent-build-composition.test.mjs", "public/src/v117-build-activation-reference.mjs", "tests/v117-four-unresolved-real-evidence.test.mjs", "docs/V117_THREE_CATEGORY_BUILD_EFFECTS_20261102.md", "tests/v117-mixed-talisman-rune-tear.test.mjs" ], "release": "EXACT_ACTIVATION_AND_THREE_CATEGORY_SCENES_ONLY__ARBITRARY_EFFECT_STACKS_NOT_CERTIFIED", "actualSwitchReferenceRun": 41376804251, "actualSwitchReferencePasses": 2, "verifiedSwitchStateCount": 4, "historicalSelectedOnlyReferenceStatus": "SUPERSEDED_CONTRADICTED_BY_OFF_OFF_ACTIVATION_PROOF" } }, "unobservableData": { "weaponRequirements": { "unobservable": 27, "reason": "Reference UI does not render accepted values for these entries, not numeric failures" }, "legacyArmor": { "unobservable": 19, "reason": "Unavailable, duplicate or miscategorised exact source items, not zero-valued numerical failures" }, "nonzeroDefenseSpell": { "status": "NO_COMPARATOR_INPUT", "reason": "Public v1.17 Spell UI assumes zero enemy defences and resistances" }, "buildRunePhysickActivation": { "status": "FOUR_TRUE_SWITCH_STATES_OBSERVED_TWICE", "reason": "Actual ON/OFF checkboxes were controlled in two independent v1.17 Chrome sessions; 4 unbuffed states + 4 combined Starscourge/Great Rune/Tear states now verified. Old selected-only OFF/OFF claim is superseded and barred from numeric previews.", "sourceRun": 41376804251 } }, "currentGameProof": { "target": "Game client App 1.17.2 / Regulation 1.17.3", "approvedGameClientGoldens": 0, "status": "NOT_CERTIFIED_FROM_REFERENCE_SITE_ONLY", "note": "Transparency only; not an additional numerical gate for v1.17 site parity." }, "stopRepeatRule": "Do not re-run historic 487 weapon or 568 armor audits, do not recheck the 24 Pebble and 13 other simple-sorcery exact goldens or a single selected-effect combination just to raise counts. Reopen only the specific blocked functionality when a genuinely new independent source or game-client observation exists. Never reinterpret CI green as whole-engine numerical parity.", "nextReopenPrerequisites": [ "Armor: new same-input Tarnished.dev v1.17 armor pool/13-metric scores/top-five ordering with observable reference rows", "Damage: new same-input, visibly observed Tarnished.dev v1.17 damage outputs and necessary enemy/motion settings", "Spell: additional visibly observed v1.17 spell inputs or new spell/catalyst formula coverage; zero-defense-only site features must not be tested against invisible enemy inputs", "Build: new observable v1.17 reference activation toggles and output-level same-input combinations; unchecked selection is not activation" ], "legacyDocs": "docs/FOUR_ENGINE_REAL_SITE_ACCEPTANCE_20261102.md contains historical pre-upgrade spell examples; not a current final acceptance summary", "comparatorOnlyDecision": "Four limited modules accepted; 0 full v1.17 website parity certified; current game-client goldens are OUT_OF_SCOPE for comparator acceptance." }, "comparatorAcceptancePolicy": { "benchmark": "Tarnished.dev", "version": "public v1.17", "soleNumericalPassAuthority": true, "requireCurrentGameClientGoldens": false, "minimumMatchingEvidence": "two independent real Chromium reads with same effective site inputs plus exact local output", "statuses": [ "MATCH", "MISMATCH", "UNOBSERVABLE", "LOCAL_ONLY", "OUT_OF_SCOPE" ], "fullFourEngineParityCertified": false, "notes": "Game-client verification and licensing are separate from v1.17 website numerical parity. Zero official-game samples do not invalidate a real v1.17 website match; absent reference inputs cannot be accepted as MATCH." } }